This is a tough one. I often actually come up with a title and write a story based on it, not the other way around!
Some books are titled by a relevant phrase or concept in the story. Take a look at the important themes or any quotes that stand out as interesting writing.
A helpful thing to remember is that it shouldn’t misrepresent your story. You shouldn’t call it, say, “True Love’s Kiss” if there’s no romance in it.
I like to also think of it in a marketing context. Write out a description of your story as if it were going on the back cover, to entice new readers. There may be some useful terms and phrases in your description.
When you’re first starting out, mimicry isn’t necessarily a bad thing. If you see a title you like or have one that’s always stood out to you, then you can mimic its style in the terms of your own story.
Rachelle Gardner has some more ideas for working toward choosing a title:
First, make sure you know the genre of your book, and identify what kind of feeling or tone you want to convey with the title. Write it down. This is important, as I’ve seen humorous books with dead-serious titles, contemporary books whose titles say “historical romance,” novels that sound like self-help books… you get the picture. Be clear on what your title needs to instantly communicate.
Time to start brainstorming:
→ Find twenty books on Amazon that are in the same genre as yours and whose titles you like. Write down their titles. Try to get a feel for what works with your genre. What do you like about the titles? What don’t you like? Then put the list away for awhile.
→ Sit with a pencil and paper (and maybe your critique group and a white-board) and free-associate, making lists of words related to your book. Put them in columns: nouns, verbs, adjectives. If it’s a novel, list words that describe or suggest the setting. Then think about each of your major characters and write down words that relate to them. Think about the action in the story and write down verbs that capture it. If your book is non-fiction, list words that capture what you want your reader to think, feel or do after reading it. And words that describe what your book is about.
→ Nothing is off limits—write down anything you can think of that conveys anything about your book. Use visual words that suggest a scene. Other words that evoke an emotion. A sensation. A location. A question. You should have at least 100 words.
→ See if any of the words would work as a single-word title. Then start experimenting with different word combinations. Adjective-noun, verb-noun. Keep a thesaurus handy and look up other words. Write down as many word combinations as you can. Try not to self-censor at this stage.
→ From these lists, come up with at least 20 possible titles. Then put them away for 24 hours. Two things will happen: your subconscious may still be working on it; and when you come back to your list, you’ll have fresh eyes.
→ Go back to your title list. Add any new ideas you’ve had. Then narrow it down to three to five possibilities. Run them by a few people. (This may or may not help, depending on if there’s a consensus or the opinions are all over the map.) Take a little more time before narrowing it down to one. If you can, wait another day or two.
→ Remember your list of titles from Amazon? Go back to it. Ask yourself if the title you’ve chosen would fit the list—without being too similar or generic.
A few more questions to ask about your title:
-Does the tone of the title match the tone of the book?
-Does it convey the right genre (including time period if applicable)?
-Would it attract attention?
-If the book were spine-out on the shelf (so the cover and sub-title were not visible) would it still attract attention?
-Would a reader have any idea what the book is about just from the title? (Sometimes important for non-fiction.)
You can also look at GoodReads’ voted “best book titles” for some inspiration.
So there’s no one good way to choose a title! It just needs to fit your story and what you want to convey about it.
I hope this helps!
Feeling generous and want to thank me for my work on this blog? Then please click here and donate to me via PayPal!
You can also become a patron of me on Patreon.
I edit blog posts for $5 each via Fiverr. I’d love to help you out!
Don’t have a dime to spare? That’s totally fine! 🙂 Thanks for your support~!